In
your role as an editor, what are some specific elements in a manuscript that
makes you say Ah-ha! this story works and what make a great book?
First off, I’d like to point out a many publishing
houses are specializing in specific genres. For example, Tor publishes a lot of
fantasy, while others look for different genres. Writers need to look closely
at guidelines and publishers’ catalogs before submitting material for
consideration. A list of children’s publishers such as the one at http://www.everywritersresource.com/childrensbookpublishers.html
indicates even among these publishers, there are requests for certain types of
literature such as: picture books,
middle grade, young adult, Christian, Caribbean, Native American, historical,
or non-fiction.
In my role as editor, I’ve seen all kinds of
submissions from ones making me want to see more from the author to those
making me wonder why a writer thought the story was worth submitting. This
seems particularly true of children’s authors. For some reason, writers think
crafting a story for children is easy. Unfortunately, just because the story is
shorter, it isn’t necessarily easier to write.
The first things I look for in a book are good
grammar, correct spelling, and proper sentence structure. Then, I’m interested
in character development and characters for whom I can cheer. If the main
characters are too perfect or have no redeeming qualities, I’m not going to
care about them.
I want to read a strong hook at the beginning of the
book. The author should jump right into the action, rather than give a detailed
description of the main character’s hometown. Then, I’m looking for a strong
plot with obstacles for the characters to overcome. Even in a short picture
book, there should be at least three challenges for the main character. These
challenges should help the character grow before the conclusion of the story.
The story should move forward smoothly with
transitions from chapter to chapter urging the reader to turn the page. The
book should have a logical conclusion arrived at through a series of plausible
events.
Throughout the story, I expect tight writing. An
author who relies on weak adjectives or adverbs instead of strong nouns and
verbs needs to work harder on her craft. Good dialogue is important, and the
author should try not to use clever words to express the word “said.” Said after dialogue is skimmed over by the
reader. With the character’s name attached: Jane said, the reader knows who
said the words but isn’t interrupted, as he would be reading: Jane admonished.
If the author wants to avoid using said all the time, the other option would be
action tags: Jane shook her finger at Paul.
Obviously, before submitting, authors need to know
their genre and what works or doesn’t. Someone writing an historical novel
should be aware of what happens in the era in which the story is set. You can’t
just guess at what is appropriate. Research is imperative for the story to ring
true. The tiniest mistake can take a reader out of the story. Something as
simple as having someone look at a book of Shakespeare when the story’s setting
is 1492 will cause the reader to put the book down. An author writing fantasy
needs to create a believable world and be sure the rules of magic are consistent
and have consequences. A wizard can’t go around throwing spells without
preparation or training. A middle grade novel shouldn’t have the parents
solving the problems of the young protagonists.
I’m not sure if there is ever an “ah ha” moment for
me. When assessing a book for acquisition, I have to put aside my personal
tastes (which tend to lean toward fantasy, science fiction, and paranormal) and
look for a well-written book submitted by an author who took the time to read
through the publisher’s guidelines and look at other books in the publisher’s
catalog.
Nancy, thank you for hosting me on your blog. You
asked a couple of great questions, and I hope I’ve been able to aid some of
your readers in their quest to become published authors. More about me and my
work can be found at http://pennylockwoodehrenkranz.yolasite.com
and at my blog http://pennylockwoodehrenkranz.blogspot.com/
Penny, you’ve given us a ton of great information. Thanks,
Penny, for visiting on my blog. I wish you much success with your books and your
work as an editor.
Alison Davis Lyne is visiting this blog again with more illustrations tips for writers. I don't illustrate, but I write picture books with the illustrator in mind.
Call for Submissions for Young Writers:
Creative Kids Magazine. We are looking for the very best material by students (ages
8–16). Material may include cartoons, songs, stories between 500 and 1200
words, puzzles, photographs, artwork, games, editorials, poetry, and plays, as
well as any other creative work that can fit in the pages of the magazine.
All
work must be original. Upon
acceptance of a work, we will request that a legal guardian sign our standard
contract granting copyright permission. The contract will be mailed with
notification of acceptance.
Work may
be submitted by the author, parent, or teacher. Each piece must be labeled
with the child’s name, birthday, grade, school, and home address, and must
include a cover letter.
Submission guidelines at http://www.ckmagazine.org/submissions/
Call for Submissions for Adult Writers:
Youth Imagination is interested in
creative fiction stories by teens as well as by adult authors. Make the stories
awesome, inspiring and engaging. Our goal is to publish the best writing for
and by teens. We particularly love stories exploring the issues, such as
bullying, drugs, romance, school, parental issues, teacher issues, etc., as
well as about the grit and character of teens and young adults.
We accept most genres of fiction,
including modern, urban or classical fantasy, as well as sci-fi, slipstream,
literary, action-adventure or suspense.
Submission guidelines at http://www.youthimagination.org/index.php/publish/submissions
Hi Nancy, thanks for having me here again this week. I hope I've provided your readers with some helpful information.
ReplyDeleteThere is a lot of really valuable information in this post. Thanks for sharing it.
ReplyDeleteThe points you look for in children's submissions seem to be the important points in any submission. And I've found that short stories are the hardest to write!
ReplyDelete